Beyond Grammar-Based English Teaching: A Better Way to Learn
Why does years of grammar-based English teaching often fail to translate into natural, spontaneous communication for the majority of learners?
One possible explanation lies in the way English is traditionally taught, particularly the widespread reliance on grammatical syllabuses. For decades, English language coursebooks have relied heavily on grammatical syllabuses, presenting structures in a predetermined sequence: the verb to be, the present simple, the present continuous, the past simple, the past continuous and so on.
But does second language acquisition actually follow such a predictable, linear progression?
In my experience as an English language teacher, the answer is no. Language acquisition is rarely a neat, linear process. Learners develop at different rates, acquire grammatical structures in different ways and often need language that has very little to do with the carefully sequenced content found in coursebooks.
In this article, I'll explore the limitations of grammar-based English teaching, explain why a more personalised approach can be beneficial and share some insights from my own experience of learning Serbian.
What is a Grammatical Syllabus?
A grammatical syllabus is developed according to the structures of a language.
Typically, the grammatical syllabus begins with the verb ‘be’, then the present simple, then the present continuous, and so forth.
Structures that are perceived to be “easy” come at the beginning of a grammatical syllabus.
What Did Ken Carroll Say About Linear Learning?
Here’s a sample of what entrepreneur Ken Carroll wrote about ELT coursebooks which follow a grammatical syllabus in an article pertaining to linear and non-linear learning:
English language textbooks for decades, have begun with present tense (aspect) verbs with an emphasis on the 3rd person. It’s always the first lesson. Thereafter the books invariably proceed with simple past tense, then past continuous, and so on. In fact, however, most learners of English do not ‘acquire’ the earliest items until they reach an advanced stage of fluency. It’s obvious that these sequence of items are presented out of expediency. The question is, however, whose expediency - the teachers’ or the students’?
Is the Present Simple Really the Easiest Tense to Master?
Many ELT coursebook writers set the ball rolling with the present simple. There’s always been this assumption in the world of ELT that it’s the “easiest” aspect to master. However, just because a grammatical structure is introduced early doesn't mean learners acquire it early.
Why does this murky fallacy regarding the simplicity of acquiring the present simple tense still prevail?
Well, human beings are habitual creatures. The present simple is related to habits - things we do day in, day out. Therefore, it must be an easy aspect to pick up because we are never going to forget our habits, are we?
Unfortunately, even advanced learners continue to use the present continuous instead of the present simple. This may be because their mother tongue does not have two distinct present tense aspects. Polish is one example of such a language.
Is Third-Person Singular -s Easy to Acquire?
Again, the answer is no.
In theory, it sounds easy to just bung an ‘s’ or ‘es’ at the end of a verb. He PLAYS ... She GOES … He NEEDS …
Heck, school pupils breeze through all those present simple gap-fill exercises thinking that they’ve mastered the present simple.
The third-person singular -s can remain problematic even for advanced learners, particularly those whose first languages do not have an equivalent grammatical feature. Its acquisition is influenced by factors including L1 background, frequency and linguistic salience.
For many learners of English, the third person singular -s is a late-acquired item. According to Krashen's (1982) Natural Order Hypothesis, the "average" order of acquisition of grammatical morphemes for English reveals that the third person singular -s is acquired later than, for instance, the progressive marker ing, plural forms (two dogs) and articles (a, the). Unfortunately, some learners never acquire the third person morpheme -s. This may be down to a concept known as fossilisation.
Vanpatten and Benati (2015, p.119) define fossilization thus:
Fossilization is a concept that refers to the end-state of SLA, specifically to an end-state that is not native-like. By end-state, we mean that point at which the learner’s mental representation of language, developing system, or interlanguage (all are related constructs) ceases to develop.
What is Non-Linear Learning?
As Mr Carroll pointed out, non-linear learning suggests that we learn through discovery, direct experience and dealing with things as they coincidentally arise:
"So, what is non-linear learning? On one level, non-linear learning is the way that we naturally learned for a couple of hundred thousand years. In nature, linear learning doesn’t exist. People didn’t learn to swim or hunt in a linear way – through a staggered, textbook process. We learned instead by doing, through direct experience, through dealing with things as they arose, and through discovering what it was that was important at the time. But most of all, we learned through making connections between stuff we already knew and the stuff we didn’t. This meant we actively constructed the knowledge as we needed it. It was all very subjective and individual and not linear."
What is Dogme ELT?
With regard to second language learning, some of the best classes I have taught were completely unplanned. I simply relied on realia and the wonders of taking an interest in my students’ lives. The unpredictable flow of such spontaneous lessons means that the learning of new lexis and grammar structures is purely incidental.
Regarding my opposition to ‘resource heavy’ teaching and grammatical syllabuses, it's worth checking out a materials-light approach to teaching called Dogme.
Proponents of a Dogme approach argue that language learning is an emergent process (Meddings and Thornbury, 2009). But what does it mean to say that language emerges? According to Meddings and Thornbury (2009:18), emergent language refers to language that arises naturally from learners' attempts to communicate, rather than language that has been predetermined by a teacher, textbook or grammatical syllabus.
The said authors view language emergence as operating on two levels:
1. Interpersonal emergence: Language arises through interaction between learners and teachers as they attempt to express ideas, exchange opinions, tell stories and negotiate meaning.
2. Cognitive emergence: As learners participate in these interactions, their internal language system (interlanguage) develops in response to the language they produce and encounter.
This is a vital distinction: emergent language is not simply language that students produce spontaneously. It is also related to the gradual development of their underlying linguistic system.
My Experience of Acquiring Serbian
The term “language acquisition” implies that languages are picked up through exposure rather than through direct teaching. Well, I did hire a teacher to help me learn Serbian - but I rather referred to her as a “guide” instead of a teacher. The reason is because I always had a lot of grammar-based and vocabulary-based questions for her based on:
1. Language that emerged from the basic conversations I was having with my wife and her family
2. My total immersion in the Serbian language in Serbia and Bosnia where I heard and saw the same old words and phrases on a daily basis
I remember picking up complex conditional structures before I learned how to ask basic questions in the present and past tenses. For example, I learned this third-conditional-type sentence early on and it has stuck out in my mind since around 2011:
Da sam imao novac, išao bih u Hrvatsku
[If I had had the money, I would have gone to Croatia]
Overall, there was no structure to the way I mastered Serbian grammar. Coincidence, exposure and intrigue meant that my own tutor had little choice but to take a non-linear journey with me.
Why Personalised Language Learning Matters
My acquisition of Serbian turned out to be anything but “linear”. That’s because I developed a Personalised Word-Phrase Table at the start of my learning. Here is a sample from my table:

In the world of English language teaching, adult beginner learners must firstly learn the days of the week, months, colours and names of food. These items shouldn't automatically take precedence over language that is immediately relevant to an individual learner.
With regard to the sample from my table above, there is no way in a million years that a beginner or elementary learner attending a language school would learn words such as “proud” and “additional” in their first few classes. However, there should be no discrimination whatsoever when it comes to the learning of vocabulary. Essentially, it is unrealistic to grade vocabulary in terms of difficulty and apparent usefulness.
Conclusion: One size fits nobody
I believe that many owners of private language schools, Directors of Studies and TEFL (Teaching English as a Foreign Language) teachers are loath to step out of their comfort zones in order to take their students down a road of discovery and exploration. An overreliance on predetermined grammatical syllabuses, however, fails to reflect the complex, individual and often non-linear nature of second language acquisition.
It is my contention that the Lexical Approach reaps greater rewards for English language learners than grammar-based English teaching. Central to the Lexical Approach is the learning of lexical chunks. The speech of proficiency speakers of English largely consists of strings of words (namely lexical chunks) that are stored and automatically retrieved as prefabricated units (Wray, 2002). To illustrate this, Erman and Warren (2000) conducted a study examining the average proportion of multi-word combinations, or prefabs, across different text types. Their findings revealed that such combinations accounted for an impressive 58.6% of spoken discourse.
At English Coach Online, I believe that effective language learning should be built around the individual rather than a predetermined sequence of grammatical structures. My approach combines meaningful communication, personalised learning materials, vocabulary development and strategies designed to help learners become more fluent and confident.
Discover my approach to English fluency →
References:
Еrmаn, В. & Warren, В. (2000) 'Тhе idiom principle and the ореп choice principle', Text, 20 (1), рр.29-62.
Krashen, S.D. (1982). Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition, Oxford: Pergamon Press
Meddings, L., & Thornbury, S. (2009). Teaching Unplugged: Dogme in English Language Teaching. Delta Publishing.
Vanpatten, B., and Benati, A.G. (2015). Key Terms in Second Language Acquisition, Second Edition, Bloomsbury Academic: London
Wray, A. (2002). Formulaic Language and the Lexicon, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
